How did goitre surgery become safer? Kocher’s story

Goitre surgery was once very dangerous. How did Kocher, Reverdin and their patients contribute to understanding the importance of the thyroid gland?

An operation once feared

The surgeon Samuel Gross wrote that no honest and sensible surgeon would attempt to remove an enlarged thyroid.[8] In this article, I tell the story of how goitre surgery became safer through the work of the surgeon Theodor Kocher.

The thyroid is a small gland in our neck that produces hormones; a goitre is a swelling at the front of the neck caused by the swelling of this gland.[9] A severe goitre can make breathing difficult, so surgeons tried to remove the gland.[1] But this operation was risky and could cause serious health problems.[1]

Before the introduction of antisepsis, a method that protects wounds from germs, patients often died from problems that arose immediately after surgery.[4] Antisepsis brought a marked improvement in this respect, so operations to remove the entire gland became much more common.[4]

What did Kocher do in Bern?

In 1872, Kocher became head of the university surgical clinic in Bern, Switzerland.[2] He showed how the operation could be performed more safely, with good hygiene and very little blood loss.[1]

Sources give different death rates for Kocher’s first 101 operations: Kopp gives 12.8%[7]; Sarkar and colleagues give 2.4%.[8] In a series of 600 patients reported in 1898, there was only 1 death; after that, the death rate in Kocher’s operations remained below 1%.[7] In his 1909 Nobel lecture, Kocher said that they had reported 300 or more consecutive goitre operations without a single death.[3]

1883: What did former patients teach us?

Over time, a problem was noticed: even when the operation and recovery went well, a considerable number of patients whose entire gland had been removed experienced a serious decline in their general health after some time.[3, 4] In the late 1870s, physiology books still described the function of this gland as a complete mystery.[4] According to Kocher, surgeons also quietly assumed that the gland had no function[5]; he himself had thought so for a long time.[5]

In early February 1883, Kocher invited 77 of his 102 former patients for an examination.[5] Of the 34 patients whose entire thyroid had been removed, 18 came for examination.[5] Only 2 of them were in the same general condition as before or better.[5] The health of the 28 patients who had benign disease and had only part of their gland removed was considered very good.[5]

Kocher called this condition “cachexia strumipriva”, meaning a poor condition resulting from the removal of a goitre.[6] Its symptoms included muscle weakness, swelling of the face and limbs, anaemia and a decline in intelligence.[4] The importance of the gland could only be successfully studied after these observations by surgeons in people.[4] Eventually, it was understood that the gland produced a secretion that reached various parts of the body.[4]

Was Kocher the first to notice this? The Geneva surgeon Jaques-Louis Reverdin had made his first report on 13 September 1882.[6] Kocher’s presentation was on 4 April 1883.[6] The two had spoken on a steamship a few days before Reverdin’s presentation in Geneva.[6] Kocher later claimed that he had told Reverdin about the harms of removing the entire thyroid; Reverdin maintained that he had given the advice.[6]

According to Kopp, Kocher and the Reverdins most likely reached the same conclusion independently; they then disputed for a long time who had discovered it first.[7] Slater, on the other hand, writes that there is every indication that Reverdin’s encouragement in September 1882 prompted Kocher to review his former patients.[6] In 1909, Kocher received the Nobel Prize in Physiology or Medicine for his work on the physiology, pathology and surgery of the thyroid gland.[1] The prize was awarded to him alone.[1] Slater reports that the view was also expressed that the prize should perhaps have been shared with Reverdin.[6]

The solution: leaving part of the gland and replacing what is missing

Kocher showed that a functioning part of the gland should be left in place during surgery.[1] But could the missing function of the gland be replaced?

In 1891, George Murray reported that an extract prepared from sheep thyroid and given by injection could improve myxoedema, or severe thyroid deficiency.[7] In 1893, Kocher also reported that eating raw thyroid tissue relieved or cured the symptoms of cachexia strumipriva.[7]

Eventually, removal of the entire thyroid was abandoned; partial operations that left the back of the gland in place replaced it.[7] But Kocher soon noticed that the goitre returned after these “subtotal” operations, in which a part was left behind.[7] According to Kopp, this problem could only be reduced through the iodisation of salt after 1920 and the availability of the hormone thyroxine in the 1930s.[7] The method of removing the entire thyroid by proceeding along the membrane surrounding the gland was only used again from the 1980s.[7]

What does this mean today?

Today, if the entire thyroid is removed, thyroid hormone tablets are needed for life after surgery.[10] If only one half of the gland is removed, depending on your thyroid function, the remaining half may produce all the hormone your body needs; if it cannot, you may need tablets for life.[10] The tablet dose is checked with regular blood tests.[12] Keep taking the tablet unless your doctor tells you to stop.[12] Some medicines and supplements may not work well with this tablet[12]; tell your doctor about the other medicines, herbal products, vitamins and supplements you take.[12] If you are unsure how to take the tablet, ask your pharmacist or doctor.[12]

Surgery today is not without risks either.[10] Even so, overall, the vast majority of people who have the operation recover without problems.[11] You can read about how the operation is performed today and its risks on the Goitre and thyroid nodules page. The “When is it an emergency?” box on the same page sets out how quickly you need to act after surgery or if you have a symptom related to your goitre.

If you notice swelling at the front of your neck, see a doctor.[9] If you are having difficulty breathing or hear a wheezing sound when you breathe, call 112 or go to the nearest emergency department.[9] Do not drive yourself to the emergency department; have someone take you or call 112.[9]

This article is for general information; it does not replace an examination.

Sources

  1. Nobel Prize Outreach. Theodor Kocher – Facts (Nobel Prize in Physiology or Medicine 1909). NobelPrize.org, 2026 (Accessed: 5 October 2026).
  2. Nobel Foundation. Theodor Kocher – Biographical. Nobel Lectures, Physiology or Medicine 1901–1921, Elsevier, Amsterdam, 1967; NobelPrize.org (Accessed: 5 October 2026).
  3. Kocher ET. Concerning pathological manifestations in low-grade thyroid diseases (Nobel Lecture, 11 December 1909). Nobel Lectures, Physiology or Medicine 1901–1921, Elsevier, Amsterdam, 1967, pp. 330–383; NobelPrize.org.
  4. Mörner KAH. Presentation Speech (Award ceremony speech, 10 December 1909). Nobel Lectures, Physiology or Medicine 1901–1921, Elsevier, Amsterdam, 1967; NobelPrize.org (Accessed: 5 October 2026).
  5. Tröhler U. Towards endocrinology: Theodor Kocher's 1883 account of the unexpected effects of total ablation of the thyroid. Journal of the Royal Society of Medicine, 2011.
  6. Slater S. The discovery of thyroid replacement therapy. Part 2: the critical 19th century. Journal of the Royal Society of Medicine, 2011.
  7. Kopp P. Theodor Kocher (1841-1917): Nobel Prize Centenary 2009. Arquivos Brasileiros de Endocrinologia e Metabologia, 2009.
  8. Sarkar S, Banerjee S, Sarkar R, Sikder B. A Review on the History of "Thyroid Surgery". Indian Journal of Surgery, 2016.
  9. NHS. Goitre. NHS.uk, last reviewed 11 March 2026 (Accessed: 5 October 2026).
  10. American Thyroid Association. Thyroid Surgery (patient information). thyroid.org, © 2026 (Accessed: 5 October 2026).
  11. American Thyroid Association. Post Operative Expectations (patient information). thyroid.org, © 2026 (Accessed: 5 October 2026).
  12. NHS. Levothyroxine. NHS.uk, last reviewed 6 July 2026 (Accessed: 5 October 2026).

I would like a call back to arrange an appointment · Contact